Kweku AnansiAsante living memory

1874 - 1900

Why the army could no longer be raised: one historian's argument

Manuel Manu-Osafo's article of 2021 offers an explanation for the military collapse that does not rest only on British weapons. The Asante army, he argues, had always depended on consent wrapped around compulsion. Men served because chiefs could make them, but also because the state kept its side of a bargain: it led well, fed and protected its people, and honoured the brave. From 1873 the state broke that bargain repeatedly. Kofi Karikari emptied the treasury, gave the command to a general unfit for it, and refused to recall a starving army unless the chiefs paid. He then robbed the royal tombs and was removed in 1874 by the Kumase chiefs without, it was said, the consent of the outer states. Mensa Bonsu ruled harshly and was thrown out by commoners in 1883. Five years of civil war followed in which ordinary people were pressed to fight for rival office-holders. By the 1890s the institutions that had forced men into the line, the oaths, the sword-bearers, the shaming of dodgers, no longer had the weight to do it, the treasury was empty, and the population had been thinned by death and flight. He quotes a Kumase man, Kwabena Osei of Adiebeba, who refused to fight in 1900 on the ground that the chiefs' power was finished.

Key facts

  • Manu-Osafo: the state's power to coerce soldiers eroded between 1874 and 1896.
  • Kofi Karikari was deposed in 1874 after taking gold from the royal mausoleum at Bantama.
  • In 1900 many men simply declined to fight and could not be made to.