Kweku AnansiAsante living memory

1800-1921

A British verdict: 'conquered but never governed'

Sir Francis Fuller, Chief Commissioner of Ashanti from 1905 to 1920, drew on Kumase informants for his history A Vanished Dynasty (1921). His summary of the empire at Osei Bonsu's accession about 1800 is a useful checklist. Gyaman, Banda, Wenchi, Takyiman, Nkoranza and Atebubu were directly held or dependent; Asante control reached north to Yendi; and Kwahu, Assin, Adanse, Wassa, Denkyira and Sefwi lay within it to the south and west. Friendly messages came from Dahomey, Yendi and Kong. Fuller drew a sharp line between two kinds of conquest. Peoples close to Asante, he wrote, were absorbed as citizens: they owed tribute and service but were otherwise left alone. Peoples beyond what he called the natural borders, above all Akyem, were beaten in battle again and again but never administered, so that they evaded their obligations and rose whenever they could. His judgement was that the Asante knew how to conquer their enemies but 'never learnt to rule them'. This is the opinion of a colonial governor who had himself ruled Asante and had reason to think British methods better; Arhin and Wilks later argued almost the opposite, that the provincial system was a serious and partly successful experiment in government. Fuller's own evidence, however, supports a middle view: near provinces were integrated, distant ones only taxed.

Note on the sources

Fuller (1921) judged provincial rule a failure; Arhin (1967) saw a deliberate and fluid political structure. Fuller's dates for the early kings (Osei Tutu 1695-1731) are the old colonial chronology.

Key facts

  • Fuller lists Gyaman, Banda, Wenchi, Takyiman, Nkoranza and Atebubu as dependent about 1800.
  • He says nearby conquered peoples were absorbed as citizens owing tribute.
  • He singled out Akyem as conquered but never governed.
  • Fuller was Chief Commissioner of Ashanti, writing in 1921.