Kweku AnansiAsante living memory

1700-1896 (scholarship of 1967-2021)

Provinces, protectorates, tributaries: three scholars' maps of Greater Asante

Historians do not agree on how to describe the parts of the empire. Kwame Arhin, in 'The Structure of Greater Ashanti' (1967), argued that the old picture of Asante wars as slave raids or attempts to open trade roads missed the point. He saw a deliberate political experiment: a 'Greater Ashanti' under the Golden Stool. He sorted the conquered lands into three kinds by their political distance from Kumase. Provinces were mostly Akan-speaking neighbours treated as part of the political structure. Protectorates were treated as allies or protected peoples as circumstances required. Tributaries supplied the wealth and manpower for further expansion. He stressed that the relationships were fluid and changed with Asante's fortunes. Ivor Wilks, in Asante in the Nineteenth Century (1975), preferred a geographical scheme: a metropolitan region around Kumase, then inner provinces, then outer provinces, with the state understood as the Asantehene and his Kumase office-holders. A 2021 article by Manu-Osafo sets the two side by side and adds T. C. McCaskie's view that both models say too little about how ordinary people consented to or resisted the state. For a heritage reader the lesson is that no single map of 'the Asante empire' is neutral: where one draws the lines depends on whether one is asking about law, tribute, language or loyalty.

Note on the sources

Arhin places the Asantemanhyiamu (national assembly) at the centre of the state; Wilks places the Asantehene and Kumase officials there and treats the assembly as mainly judicial. Wilks's own definitions were not read directly in this session.

Key facts

  • Arhin (1967) divided the empire into provinces, protectorates and tributaries.
  • Wilks (1975) divided it into a metropolitan region, inner provinces and outer provinces.
  • Arhin argued the conquests built a political community, not just trade routes or slave supplies.
  • Arhin's 'Asante proper' centred on Kumase, Mampon and Dwaben.