Kweku AnansiAsante living memory

1824 onwards

MacCarthy's head: what is said and by whom

The fate of Sir Charles MacCarthy's head is one of the best-known stories of the wars, and it should be read as a set of reports and not as an established fact. Fuller, who governed Asante and talked to its elders, wrote that the head was sent to Kumase, that a gold cast was made of the skull, and that the skull itself was added to a collection of enemy skulls kept as a war shrine; he lists the cast with those of five African rulers in the royal treasury. Reindorf, from coast informants, says MacCarthy was wounded with poisoned weapons and killed and that the captives were beheaded. The Wikipedia article on the battle repeats a claim, sourced to a journal of 1873, that a skull rimmed with gold and said to be his was used as a drinking cup by Asante kings. That date is telling: the story was in wide circulation in Britain as Wolseley's expedition was being prepared, and it served to justify it. Fuller's account says nothing of a cup. The same article says the prisoner Williams was kept for a time with the heads of MacCarthy and Wetherell, but marks the statement as unsourced. Fuller adds a detail the Asante gave him: Osei Bonsu died on the very day MacCarthy was killed.

Note on the sources

Gold cast and shrine skull (Fuller) against use as a gold-rimmed drinking cup (British reports from 1873). No Asante-side source for the cup was found.

Key facts

  • Fuller: a gold cast was made of the skull and kept in the treasury; the skull joined a shrine of skulls.
  • The drinking-cup story rests on an 1873 British journal (per Wikipedia).
  • Fuller records the tradition that Osei Bonsu died on the day of the battle.