nineteenth century; debate 1980s
Killing at royal funerals: reports and historians' arguments
akyere
European visitors from Bowdich onward reported that people were put to death at the funerals of kings and great men and at the annual Odwira, and nineteenth-century Britain made 'human sacrifice' a leading charge against Asante. Rattray's informants in the 1920s described a class of person, akyere, set aside for death at funeral customs, said that slaves could be chosen, and insisted that only the chief could authorise a killing and that his own executioners carried it out. What these deaths were is disputed. In 1988 Clifford Williams published an assessment of the period 1807-74 under the title 'Asante: human sacrifice or capital punishment?', and Ivor Wilks replied in a rejoinder in the same journal; the question was how far those killed were condemned criminals whose executions were held over for state occasions, as Wilks had argued, and how far they were innocent victims killed to serve the dead. T. C. McCaskie's 'Death and the Asantehene' (1989) studied the very fully recorded events around the death and burial of Kwaku Dua I in 1867 and interpreted them through Asante ideas about death and kingship. A single documented case shows the practice outliving the kingdom: in 1925 the Kumawuhene Kwame Afram showed Prempeh I a bound Grunshi slave whom he proposed to kill for the exiles who had died abroad. Prempeh left at once and said nothing; the government later dropped its case against the chief.
The Williams and Wilks articles (International Journal of African Historical Studies 21, 1988) could not be opened; only their titles and the general shape of the disagreement are reported, and the summary of each position should be checked against the texts. Numbers killed on any occasion are not given here because none was verified.
Key facts
- Rattray recorded that only a chief could authorise the killing of a slave or akyere.
- Williams and Wilks debated 'human sacrifice or capital punishment' in 1988.
- In 1925 the Kumawuhene proposed to kill a slave in honour of dead exiles.