Kweku AnansiAsante living memory

1820s - 1880s

'Peace party' and 'war party': a reading and its critics

Ivor Wilks read nineteenth-century Asante politics as a contest between two broad tendencies in council. One, which he called the peace party, held that the nation's interest lay in trade and open roads and that relations with the British should be managed by negotiation. The other, the war party, held that the southern provinces and Elmina must be kept or retaken by force and that British officials could not be trusted to honour the 1831 treaty. The biographical entries written by Wilks and J. K. Fynn use these labels throughout: Osei Yaw Akoto took the stool with war-party support in 1824; Kwaku Dua I proclaimed 'Peace, Trade, and Open Roads' and gave way only when his opponents won a council majority in 1863; Kofi Kakari was elected on a war platform; Adu Bofo and Amankwa Tia led the war party of 1872-73, while the counselor Boakye Tenten spoke for peace. Other historians have qualified the picture. McCaskie's account of the same years stresses dynastic rivalry between royal 'houses' and personal ruthlessness more than policy. Gareth Austin rejected Wilks's related idea that an organised 'middle class' of state traders stood behind the politics of the 1880s, arguing that the decisive force in 1883 was a mass of commoners. The labels remain useful shorthand, but they describe shifting alignments, not parties with members.

Note on the sources

Wilks's own book (Asante in the Nineteenth Century) and the full critiques were not open; this record reports the framework as used in his and Fynn's biographical entries and the criticisms stated in Austin's summary and McCaskie's essay.

Key facts

  • Wilks's 'peace party' favoured trade and negotiation; his 'war party' favoured holding the south by force.
  • Austin (1996) rejected Wilks's 'organised middle class' explanation of the 1880s.