1995 - 2012
'Is Wilks right?' The archaeologists' reply
The first sustained objection to Wilks's model came from the people digging in the forest. Peter Shinnie published a paper in 1996 under the title 'Early Asante: Is Wilks Right?' and returned to the question in 2005. He called Wilks's reconstruction highly plausible as a sequence but said the time allowed for it was too short. Asantemanso was a settlement of some size by the ninth or tenth century; a place of that size cannot have lived on wild food; therefore farming in the central forest must be many centuries older than the fifteenth. He pointed out that Jan Vansina had argued for a much earlier beginning of forest agriculture in the northern Congo. Wilks answered by doubting that early Asantemanso was a town in the full sense. The environmental historian James McCann, in a book of 1999, took Wilks's side on the chronology. Gerard Chouin and Christopher DeCorse widened the attack in 2010, arguing from the earthworks and other sites that a settled farming society, well adapted to the forest, existed long before the Atlantic trade, and that its collapse in the fourteenth century, not a first clearing in the fifteenth, is the event that needs explaining. Chouin's separate paper of 2012 nevertheless warned against simply discarding the model, which he described as a complex construction to be taken apart carefully, parts of which still hold real historical information and useful hypotheses.
Wilks and McCann: forest farming societies formed late and fast. Shinnie, Chouin and DeCorse: they are many centuries older. Chouin: parts of Wilks's model remain valid.
Key facts
- Shinnie's 'Early Asante: Is Wilks Right?' appeared in 1996.
- His central point: a large 9th-10th century settlement implies farming.
- McCann (1999) supported Wilks's chronology.
- Chouin and DeCorse (2010) argue for an agrarian forest society before 1500.