Kweku AnansiAsante living memory

1940s - 1976

Eva Meyerowitz's theories and why historians rejected them

Eva Meyerowitz worked at Techiman in the 1940s with the support of the Techimanhene, Nana Akumfi Ameyaw III, and published a series of books that brought the Bono, and through them all the Akan, from Timbuktu and the 'great white desert', with ruling-class and religious institutions drawn from Saharan, Libyan-Berber, Egyptian and Near Eastern sources. She dated the founding of Bono Manso to 1295 and printed a list of thirty-seven rulers down to 1950. Her chronology rested on a reported custom in which each king put a gold nugget, and each queen mother a bead or cowrie, into a vessel every year; her interpreter counted them in 1945. The criticisms came in stages. David Tait (1953) objected that she matched names of peoples and places across great distances without method and leaned on a single Bono tradition not shared by other Akan. Colin Flight (1970) re-examined the chronology and pointed to the chief's interest in strengthening Techiman's standing against Asante. Dennis Warren, who worked in Techiman, reported in 1976 that informants she named denied giving her the information, that Timbuktu and her other place names were unknown to tradition outside circles she had influenced, that no stool in the stool room looked older than the eighteenth century, and that some chiefs she placed in the fifteenth century belonged after the Asante conquest of 1722-23. He concluded that Bono history before that conquest could not be rebuilt from the oral evidence. Her accounts had by then entered school textbooks.

Note on the sources

Meyerowitz dated Bono Manso to 1295; Effah-Gyamfi's archaeology puts settlement by the 13th century on independent grounds, but Warren and others regard her exact date and king list as unsupported.

Key facts

  • Meyerowitz dated Bono Manso's founding to 1295 and listed 37 rulers.
  • Her patron at Techiman was Nana Akumfi Ameyaw III.
  • Tait (1953), Flight (1970), Effah-Gyamfi (1979) and Warren (1976) criticised her methods.
  • Warren found informants who denied or contradicted what she attributed to them.