Kweku AnansiAsante living memory

1907 - 1940s

A king's doubt: Prempeh II on the Asantemanso story

The origin story was debated inside the royal house as well as among scholars. Agyeman Prempeh I, writing in exile in Seychelles in 1907, opened his History of Ashanti Kings with the descent of the ancestress Ankyewa Nyame from the sky and the rising of the clans from the ground at Asantemanso, and he evidently accepted it. His nephew and successor Prempeh II took a different view. According to Ivor Wilks's chapter in the scholarly edition of the History, Prempeh II told the anthropologist Meyer Fortes in the 1940s that the Asantemanso story 'is not true', although his uncle had believed it, and proposed instead that the Asante had come from far away. Prempeh II also set up a committee in the 1940s, under his own chairmanship, to compile a new history of Asante that was expected to replace his uncle's text; he is reported to have regarded the 1907 work as a family history rather than a history of the nation. The exchange shows two things. Educated Asante opinion in the mid-twentieth century was open to the long-distance theories then being published by Danquah and Meyerowitz. And the emergence story is not a single fixed doctrine: it has been affirmed, doubted and reinterpreted by the people whose history it is.

Note on the sources

Prempeh I recorded the emergence tradition as history; Prempeh II is reported to have rejected it in favour of a distant origin.

Key facts

  • Prempeh I's 1907 history begins with Ankyewa Nyame and the emergence at Asantemanso.
  • Prempeh II told Meyer Fortes in the 1940s that the story 'is not true' (reported by Wilks).
  • Prempeh II chaired a committee in the 1940s that compiled a new 'History of Ashanti'.
Asantehene Prempeh II with Governor Sir Arnold Hodson, Kumasi, 1935
Asantehene Prempeh II with Governor Sir Arnold Hodson, Kumasi, 19351935-01-31 · The National Archives UK - Flickr account · OGL v1.0 · Credit and source
The Chief Commissioner's stand as the Asantehene presents a loyal address, Kumasi, Coronation Day 1937
The Chief Commissioner's stand as the Asantehene presents a loyal address, Kumasi, Coronation Day 19371937 · The National Archives UK - Flickr account · OGL v1.0 · Credit and source
Asantehene Prempeh II and the Asantehemaa on Coronation Day, 1937
Asantehene Prempeh II and the Asantehemaa on Coronation Day, 19371937 · The National Archives UK - Flickr account · OGL v1.0 · Credit and source
Asantehene Prempeh II with the Golden Stool and his retinue at the Coronation Durbar in Kumasi, 1953
Asantehene Prempeh II with the Golden Stool and his retinue at the Coronation Durbar in Kumasi, 19531953 · The National Archives UK - Flickr account · OGL v1.0 · Credit and source