Kweku AnansiAsante living memory

to 1923

Was the high god borrowed? Rattray against Ellis

A long argument about Asante religion turns on whether belief in a Supreme Being is old. The earlier writer A. B. Ellis held that Nyankopon was a borrowed idea, a local version of the God preached by Europeans on the coast. Rattray devoted a chapter of Ashanti (1923) to rejecting this. He pointed to the altars, priests and temples of the sky god, to proverbs about Nyame that are part of everyday speech, and to the much earlier Dutch writer Bosman, who had already reported a belief in a creator. He compared Asante practice with the 'mixed' religion of ancient Israel, in which one high god stood above many lesser powers. He returned to the point when discussing a deathbed declaration rite, arguing that its force came from the words of an ancestor and so could not be a European import. Rattray's argument is itself a colonial official's reading, but it changed how outsiders wrote about Akan belief.

Note on the sources

Ellis: the Supreme Being is a borrowed concept. Rattray: it is indigenous.

Key facts

  • Ellis argued the high god was a missionary-era borrowing.
  • Rattray cited Bosman and the Nyame altars as evidence of an older belief.